Uploaded image for project: '{RETIRED} Curriki'
  1. {RETIRED} Curriki
  2. CURRIKI-6290

Discussion Rights issues

    XMLWordPrintable

Details

    • Bug
    • Resolution: Fixed
    • Major
    • NEA Phase 1
    • NEA Phase 1
    • None
    • None

    Description

      Hi Ludovic,

      http://dev.gpsnetwork.org/xwiki/bin/view/Group_TestingTodd20Group1/Discussions

      I tested Discussion Rights Editing only. Here are the results.

      Test 1
      User A - As a Group Leader added a Topic
      User B - Added an Answer
      User C - Added a comment
      User A - Added a comment

      Two Issues
      1. For some undetermined time, User A could not edit User B's Answer. The object is locked error displayed with User B currently editing. However, User B was not editing. If User B Logs Out the problem goes away. This bug is repeatable.

      2. User A could not edit User C's Comment. The error "Failure to Retrieve: Forbidden" is displayed. This is repeatable. User A could edit his own comment.

      Test 2
      User B - As a member added a Topic
      User A - As a Group Leader added an Answer
      User C - Added an Answer too.
      User A - Added a comment

      Two Issues
      1. User B, even though he created the topic could not edit User A or User C's Answers. The Edit and Delete buttons are not shown next to the answers. The Edit and Delete buttons do show on everything else.

      2. User B could not edit Users A or C's Comments. The error Failure to Retrieve: Forbidden is displayed. This is repeatable.

      Note: User C in both Test 1 and 2 was only able to edit what was appropriate.
      Note: GPS Admin had the same experience as the Group Leader. "This object is currently locked by TestingTodd1 TestingTodd1
      Click here to force editing" and the Failure to Retrieve error.

      I have not tested Delete.

      Attachments

        Activity

          People

            toddsherman Todd Sherman
            toddsherman Todd Sherman
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            3 Start watching this issue

            Dates

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: