Uploaded image for project: '{RETIRED} XWiki Wiki Macro Bridge Application'
  1. {RETIRED} XWiki Wiki Macro Bridge Application
  2. XAWMB-2

In XE-2.0M2,xwiki.virtual=1 causes bugs for groovy scripts using 2.0 Macro Bridge

    XMLWordPrintable

Details

    • Bug
    • Resolution: Duplicate
    • Critical
    • None
    • 1.0
    • None
    • None
    • groovy,virtual,macro,2.0

    Description

      2.0M2 XE release has a bug when using Groovy Macros in the 2.0 Macro Bridge.
      To demonstrate this bug, see attached RootVhostGroovyMacroPkg.xar

      2400  08-09-09 14:25   Macros/WebHome.xml
      7032  08-09-09 14:25   Macros/GroovyRandom.xml
      3131  08-09-09 14:25   Macros/GroovyRandomTest.xml
      7387  08-09-09 14:25   Macros/Weather.xml
      2177  08-09-09 14:25   Macros/WeatherMacroTest.xml
      1050  08-09-09 14:25   package.xml
       

      In order to get the attached groovy scripts to work with the 2.0 Macro Bridge, in xwiki:XWiki.XWikiPreferences?editor=globaladmin&section=Programming, the "Groovy Macro Pages" field must be set to "Macros.Weather,Macros.GroovyRandom".

      When xwiki.virtual=1 there is a bug that you need to have documents Macros.Weather and Macros.GroovyRandom on the VIRTUAL HOST, and owned by the "root" wiki admin xwiki:XWiki.Admin. If this isn't done, you get a "inadequate access privileges" error on the groovy script, unless you're running the script on the root wiki. Furthermore, these local macro-bridge documents do not override or change the original root-wiki definition setup in the xwiki:XWiki.XWikiPreferences "Macros.Weather,Macros.GroovyRandom." In 2.0M2, you can use completely empty documents for this purpose, as long as they're owned by xwiki:XWiki.Admin. The need for these"shadow" documents in the
      virtual wiki is a bug; alternately, the fact that they do nothing in the virtual-wiki (they don't allow definition of any new local macros) is a bug as well.

      What makes sense is that if the virtual-wiki defines it's own <vhost>:XWiki.XWikiPreferences "Groovy Macro Pages" entries, and these
      are owned by xwiki:XWiki.Admin for "programming rigths" in a virtual wiki, then these scripts would override or take precedence
      over globally defined ones. In fact, if any locally defined scripts exist, they should be available on that v-host as long as they're owned by xwiki:XWiki.Admin for "programming rigths".

      A second Major bug in the wiki-macro bridge is that only the first invocation "works" – all subsequent invocations fail silently. As the only way to get output from these groovy scripts is to println, I'm wonderng whether the output stream gets closed after the first invocation, causing all subsequent invocations to go "silent".

      For example the following:

      == Testing 2.0 Macro groovy_random ==
      
      1. {{groovy_random size="66"/}}
      1. {{groovy_random size="56"/}}
      1. {{groovy_random size="46"/}}
      1. {{groovy_random size="36"/}}
      1. {{groovy_random size="26"/}}
      1. {{groovy_random size="16"/}}
      1. {{groovy_random size="6"  /}}
      ...
      

      Produces the result:

      Testing 2.0 Macro groovy_random
      
         1.
            p0NhDskfp3AXkjlL7qJKwErXuVSJMKLAGhwBPLhIminTLAc9qz8yVVFAY6DD5RF6GC
         2.
         3.
         4.
         5.
         6.
         7.
         ... 
      

      Note that all the outputs subsequent to the first are empty. Last time I ran similar scripts in a non-virtual wiki, however, I believe
      all the outputs from each groovy script invocation occurred.

      By way of comparison, a number of Groovy Scripts that do not use the Wiki Macro Bridge were developed to see if the same issues arose in a virtual wiki. For example, multiple groovy scripts can be called sequentially in a document (sharing objects/variables between them), and all the outputs occur correctly, unlike above. Furthermore, no additional complications in installation occur: for example, the wiki macro bridge seems to require the "root wiki" be modified to contain macros even if you only want them on a single virtual host. This will make those macros available in all virtual-wikis, although the scripts will all fail unless xwiki:XWiki.Admin-owned "shadow documents" exist on all the virtual-host wikis.

      I think this behavior is a "bug". If scripts are to be made available across all wikis in a virtual-wiki setup, they should be defined on the root-wiki's xwiki:XWiki.XWikiPreferences -> Programming -> "Groovy Macro Pages". If they are to be available on a single virtual-wiki, as long as they're owned by the root xwiki:XWiki.Admin, they should be defined in <vhost>:XWiki.XWikiPreferences -> Programming -> "Groovy Macro Pages".

      FYI, here are the additional groovy scripts fin the second attachment, GroovyExamplesPkg.xar

      1776  08-09-09 14:58   Groovy/WebHome.xml
      2318  08-09-09 14:58   Groovy/GroovyTest1.xml
      2466  08-09-09 14:58   Groovy/GroovyTest3.xml
      2643  08-09-09 14:58   Groovy/GroovyTest4.xml
      3618  08-09-09 14:58   Groovy/SshHelperClass.xml
      2129  08-09-09 14:58   Groovy/SshHelperTest.xml
      2088  08-09-09 14:58   Groovy/TestClass1.xml
      2148  08-09-09 14:58   Groovy/TestClass2.xml
      2773  08-09-09 14:58   Groovy/VelocityCallingTestClass1.xml
      2099  08-09-09 14:58   Groovy/VelocityCallingTestClass2.xml
      1750  08-09-09 14:58   package.xml
      

      Attachments

        Issue Links

          Activity

            People

              asiri Asiri Rathnayake
              nielsmayer Niels Mayer, http://nielsmayer.com
              Votes:
              0 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              0 Start watching this issue

              Dates

                Created:
                Updated:
                Resolved: